They are saying it was the vote. I would say that his drama of holding out the vote and causing the president to sign the EO also had a big role to play in this. All in all, he did not do well with either side of the center and definitely not on the left.
Perhaps a big lesson for the entire Stupak bloc. All the members - Marcy Kaptur, Nick Rahall, etc. have cause to worry. Of course, HUGE lesson for all the Dems for the future to not to pull a Stupak on a bill in the future.
-- Edited by Sanders on Friday 9th of April 2010 08:37:00 AM
__________________
Democracy needs defending - SOS Hillary Clinton, Sept 8, 2010 Democracy is more than just elections - SOS Hillary Clinton, Oct 28, 2010
Stupak will be remembered as the Tsunami that tore down the facade of the Democratic Party Platform. He showed that they are a group of swindlers and dealmakers who talk a good game but don't consider the American people (especially women) worth a darn.
Good riddance. And Stupak honey-schnookums, you can take the rest of your flea bitten crew with you in November. Just say no to incumbents...
Here's an article from Yahoo on Stupak's retirement:
Tea Party target Stupak won't seek re-election AP
TRAVERSE CITY, Mich. – Democratic Rep. Bart Stupak, targeted for defeat by Tea Party activists for his crucial role in securing House approval of the health care overhaul, said Friday he would retire from Congress this year.
The nine-term congressman told The Associated Press he could have won re-election and insisted he wasn't being chased from the race by the Tea Party Express, which is holding rallies this week in his northern Michigan district calling for his ouster. Instead, Stupak said he was tired after 18 years in office and wanted to spend more time with his family.
"The Tea Party did not run me out," he said in a telephone interview. "If you know me and my personality, I would welcome the challenge."
Stupak, 58, said he had considered retirement for years but was persuaded to stay in Congress because of the prospect of serving with a Democratic majority and helping win approval of the health care overhaul, which he described as his top legislative priority.
"I've fought my whole career for health care and thanks to Barack Obama and my colleagues, we've gotten it done," he said.
A political moderate, Stupak is known for an independent streak that sometimes put him at odds with his party's leadership. He voted against the North American Free Trade Agreement and an assault weapons ban in the 1990s, despite appeals from then-President Bill Clinton.
During the health care debate, Stupak emerged as spokesman and chief negotiator for Democrats who withheld support from Obama's plan because they feared it would allow public funding of abortions.
After the president agreed to sign an executive order pledging no federal funding of elective abortions covered by private insurance, Stupak's bloc cast the votes that provided the legislation's narrow victory.
Since then, Stupak has become a symbol for critics of the overhaul. The Tea Party Express labeled him its No. 2 target for defeat after Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada.
The group kicked off a $250,000 television and radio blitz in Stupak's district Wednesday, ahead of rallies that began Thursday night and were continuing through the weekend.
"Bart Stupak has lost touch with the people of Michigan, and he has betrayed the public's trust," said Mark Williams, the group's chairman.
Three little-known hopefuls are seeking the GOP nomination, and Stupak faced a primary challenge from a Democrat who is pro-choice on abortion.
Even so, Michigan's 1st District is notoriously difficult turf for anyone trying to unseat the incumbent. Measuring 600 miles across, it takes in about half the state's land mass — including the entire Upper Peninsula — and has no major media market. The largest city, Marquette, where Stupak was planning to officially announce his retirement later Friday, has about 20,000 residents.
Stupak has routinely won re-election by wide margins, defeating former state Rep. Tom Casperson with 65 percent of the vote in 2008, and said he was confident of prevailing again.
He acknowledged the criticism he received over the health care reform — including telephone threats to his office — had taken a toll, but said he had thrived during the debate. What wore him down, he said, was the grind of constant travel across his sprawling district.
"When I come home I can't stay home," he said. "I'm there 12 hours and take off. That has gotten hard."
Stupak said House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority Leader Steny Hoyer had urged him to seek re-election. Republicans represented his rural, blue-collar district for nearly three decades before he won in 1992, and his departure will create a strong opportunity for the GOP.
Still, he said a moderate Democrat would have a good chance.
"There are a lot of great Democratic elected officials and activists throughout the entire district. I'm confident we'll have a very strong candidate," said Mark Brewer, chairman of Michigan Democratic Party.
He said he reached his decision this week after talking with his family and was making a quick announcement to give other Democratic hopefuls time to organize and get their names on the primary election ballot.
"I feel like I can finally step away," Stupak said. "I can be home more often with my wife. I'm young enough to start a new career. I'm at peace and very comfortable with my decision."
__________________
It was we, the people; not we, the white male citizens; nor yet we, the male citizens; but we, the whole people, who formed the Union.... Men, their rights and nothing more; women, their rights and nothing less. ~Susan B. Anthony
The Dems are running scared, and with good reason. I agree with Optix - No Incumbents.
__________________
It was we, the people; not we, the white male citizens; nor yet we, the male citizens; but we, the whole people, who formed the Union.... Men, their rights and nothing more; women, their rights and nothing less. ~Susan B. Anthony