House Minority Whip Eric Cantor (R-Va.) sent a letter to President Obama Friday accusing the White House of striking a deal on the excise tax that favors federal employees.
"While the reported deal is bad enough for working Americans, I am concerned that the deal that was negotiated behind closed doors may also have been designed to benefit federal government officials and employees at the expense of other Americans," Cantor wrote.
The Minority Whip requested that the Administration answer the following questions about the compromise brokered with union representatives Thursday:
--Will the health care plans offered to Members of Congress and Administration officials, including Cabinet officers, White House staff, and political appointees, be exempt from the proposed excise tax in the same manner as those covered under collective bargaining agreements?
--Will the health care plans offered to federal employees, including over 382,000 employees making in excess of $100,000 a year, be exempt from the proposed excise tax in the same manner as those covered under collective bargaining agreements?
Cantor closed his letter with a final jab at the President, saying, "I regret that I am forced to send this" but it would not have been necessary had the Administration "had televised the health care negotiations on C-SPAN, as you committed to during the campaign."
Full letter after the jump.
By Meredith Shiner
The Honorable Barack Obama
President of the United States
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave, NW
Washington, D.C. 20500
Dear Mr. President,
I read with great interest press reports indicating that Administration officials and Democrat congressional leaders have struck a deal related to the so-called “Cadillac” tax on high cost health plans. Numerous press reports indicate that health insurance plans covering state and local government employees and plans for employees in collective bargaining agreements would be exempt from the tax until 2018, while individuals employed in the private sector that are not covered by union contracts would pay the tax as early as 2013 -- even if they have the exact same insurance coverage.
While the reported deal is bad enough for working Americans, I am concerned that the deal that was negotiated behind closed doors may also have been designed to benefit federal government officials and employees at the expense of other Americans. Specifically, I request that the Administration provide answers to the following questions prior to announcing any final agreement on a health care bill:
1. Will the health care plans offered to Members of Congress and Administration officials, including Cabinet officers, White House staff, and political appointees, be exempt from the proposed excise tax in the same manner as those covered under collective bargaining agreements?
2. Will the health care plans offered to federal employees, including over 382,000 employees making in excess of $100,000 a year, be exempt from the proposed excise tax in the same manner as those covered under collective bargaining agreements?
I regret that I am forced to send this letter. I do not believe it would be necessary if you and your Administration had televised the health care negotiations on C-SPAN, as you committed to during the campaign.
The members of the senate and house need to know the answers to Cantor's questions. The whole country needs to know. The unions threatened the Dems with losses in 2010 and 2012 if the HCR bill was passed with the tax on so-called "cadillac" insurance plans in place. Two days later, the tax has been removed.
Cantor is to be applauded for requesting accountability from Obama on this issue. And, he's absolutely correct in stating that there would be less confusion, less distrust if Obama had kept his promise of transparency, and had the meetings televised on C Span.
__________________
It was we, the people; not we, the white male citizens; nor yet we, the male citizens; but we, the whole people, who formed the Union.... Men, their rights and nothing more; women, their rights and nothing less. ~Susan B. Anthony